Traceable Quality®
Talk to us
Menu

Insight

Why the tag on the steel rack went quiet

The same UHF tag reads from about 21 m on cardboard and 2 m flat on steel. What metal, water and people do to the antenna, and the two cheap fixes.

Take one tag and one reader. Put the tag on a cardboard carton and the model has it reading from about 21 metres. Stick the same tag flat on a steel rack and the model loses it at two.

Nothing broke.

A dipole flat on steel is cancelled by its own image in the metal. Water absorbs the wave. In the model, a few millimetres of air helps by an amount that depends heavily on the stand-off, and a tag made for metal does better. The figures are modelled, not measured.

Steel

The antenna on a standard tag is a dipole: a strip of metal about a quarter of a wavelength long on each side of the chip. It works by pushing current back and forth along that strip, and the current throws a field out into the air.

Put a metal sheet right behind it and the sheet answers. A conductor can’t have an electric field running along its surface, so it makes a mirror image of the antenna, with the current running the other way. The tag’s own current and its image sit almost on top of each other, and they cancel. Right at the surface the field is close to nothing.

So the chip gets about one per cent of what it got on cardboard. In the model behind our demo, at three metres, that’s 195 microwatts on cardboard and 2.2 on steel. A UCODE 9 chip wakes at -24 dBm, which is about 4 microwatts. On cardboard it has fifty times that. On steel it’s short by half.

Water

Water does something different. It doesn’t cancel the wave, it eats it. At 866 MHz the energy goes into the water as heat, and none comes back out.

A bottle of shampoo does it. A crate of meat does it. So does a person, who is mostly water, and who walks between the reader and the pallet at the worst moment. That’s the dock door that reads fine at 2 am and badly at ten.

A tag on a water bottle, in our model, reads to about 6 m instead of 21. A person in the path costs a similar chunk, each way, and the reply pays it twice.

What to do about it

Give the tag some air. A few millimetres of foam between the label and the steel helps, by an amount that depends heavily on the stand-off. The model puts a 5 mm gap at about 14 m instead of 2, and that figure is the least certain one here: a 3 mm gap and a 10 mm gap will not give the same answer.

Or buy a tag made for metal. An on-metal tag is a patch antenna, and it uses the steel as its ground plane. It wants the metal there, and the model has it at about 16 m. It does better than a spacer, and it’s a tag designed for the job.

For water, move the tag. The top of a carton or an edge has less liquid behind it than the middle.

Check the numbers before you trust them

The penalties for each surface are typical published figures, and I haven’t measured them. The only number in this post that comes from a datasheet is the chip’s sensitivity. Everything else is a placeholder, and the demo says so on the page. We’re replacing each one with a bench reading: same tag, same reader, same distance, surface swapped.

The shape of the answer won’t change. Metal costs you the most, water costs you a lot, and a spacer or an on-metal tag helps. How much, the bench will tell us. The metres will change.

The model also assumes free space apart from the surface, and a reader that puts 1 W into 1 dB of cable and a 6 dBi antenna. That comes to 35 dBm EIRP, a hair under India’s limit of 2 W ERP. A real room will do worse than the model.

Try it

Surface test lets you drag the same tag across cardboard, plastic, glass, a bottle of water and a steel rack, with and without a spacer and a person in the way. Wake the tag shows the same sums without a surface in the middle.

If you’re signing a PO for tags, ask what they’re going on, not just what they are. A plain inlay specified for a steel cage will go quiet, and it won’t be a faulty tag.

Next step

Tell us what you are trying to trace.

Describe the flow: what arrives, what happens to it and what leaves. We will tell you what it takes to capture it.