Free tool
Barcode or RFID?
Describe the count you do and get a straight answer: which technology pays for itself here, why, and how many hours each one costs you a month.
Describe the count
Our read
| Barcode | RFID | |
|---|---|---|
| Time per count | ||
| Labour hours a month | ||
| Labour cost a month | ||
| Labels for these items, once | ||
| Label as a share of item value |
The hours are the counting itself, in free air. Finding the misplaced ones afterwards is where RFID's real saving usually hides, and it isn't in this table.
How it works
What it’s deciding
RFID earns its money in three situations. A scanner can’t reach the label. There are too many items to scan one at a time. Or nobody is there to scan, so a reader on a door or a shelf has to do the capturing. Each of your answers above pushes one way or the other, and the verdict is which side has more pushes. The reasons are listed so you can disagree with one.
The barcode wins in three others. The item is cheap enough that the tag is a real share of its price. Someone already scans it for another reason. Or you need to know which unit is in which slot. A read tells you a tag is somewhere in the antenna’s zone. A scan tells you it’s the one in your hand.
What the hours are
Barcode time is items times seconds per scan, with half as much again when labels are out of reach. RFID time is the walk past the shelving, which the item count stands in for. Both are the count in free air, with tags that read. Finding the ones that were put back in the wrong place is where RFID usually saves the most, and it isn’t in the table because it depends on how often that happens to you.
Where the numbers come from
Every assumption is under “Assumptions we started from” above, with where it came from, and you can change all of them. The tag price moves the verdict most, so check it against a real quote. Readers hear anywhere from about 50 to more than 1,000 tags a second depending on mode (Impinj reader modes, as used in the range calculator). Three seconds a scan is generous to the barcode: in the University of Arkansas pilot at Bloomingdale’s, a full store count ran at 209 items an hour by barcode and 4,767 by RFID, because most of a barcode count is finding the label. The reasoning behind this page is in Where RFID earns its money. For the longer comparison, including QR and BLE, see RFID vs barcode vs QR vs BLE. For how a tag reads at all, see Wake the tag.