Traceable Quality®
Talk to us
Menu

Insight

Which dock door did the pallet leave through?

A reader at door 1 logs a pallet that left through door 2. Nothing is misconfigured. Here is why it happens, what each fix buys, and what turns a pile of reads into one event.

The reader at door 1 just logged a pallet that left through door 2.

Nobody misconfigured anything. The reader sends 1 W to an antenna that points down the staging lane. When the forklift drove past, 8 m back, the tag woke up and answered at -66 dBm. The reader hears down to -88. So it’s a read. A perfectly good read, of the wrong pallet.

Door 1 reads a pallet that left through door 2. Each fix helps a little. Two antennas and a sensor are what make it an event.

Why the reader hears so far

Radio doesn’t stop at the door frame. A reader at full legal power is a long-range instrument, and in free space it wakes and hears a tag more than twenty metres out. An antenna on a dock door is not trying to be that. You want it to hear the pallet in the doorway and nothing else.

India’s limit is 2 W ERP, which is 35.15 dBm EIRP, on four channels between 865.7 and 867.5 MHz. That is the same ceiling as ETSI’s. 1 W into a cable with 1 dB of loss and a 6 dBi antenna is 35 dBm EIRP, so this dock is already about as loud as the rules let it be. (The 2021 rules replaced the 2005 ones, which were written around a 1 W transmitter. If you read “1 W is the limit” somewhere, that’s the old rule.)

A pallet parked in the lane is the same problem, only longer. Eight metres back, on axis, -66 dBm. It reads all afternoon.

What each fix buys

Turn the power down. At a quarter of the power the lane pass drops from -66 to -72. The reader still hears it, because it hears down to -88.

Tilt the antenna at the floor. At 60° the same pass reads -78. Better, and still heard.

Hang absorber panels on the sides of the portal. A pallet at the lane corner, turning into door 2, reads -77 at door 1 without them. Behind the panels it’s about -117, which is nothing. But a pallet on axis in the lane doesn’t care about panels.

Throw away anything quieter than -60 dBm. The lane pass goes. The pallet in the portal, at about -43, stays.

Each one helps. Each one also has a setting you’ll get wrong on some Tuesday, and the model is free space. A real dock has trucks and racking and a steel floor, and a tag there swings 10 dB either way as a truck pulls in. That’s a rule of thumb, not a measurement of ours. A fix that works in the simulator by 3 dB will not work on your dock.

Reads aren’t events

So stop trying to make the reader hear less. Change what the system concludes from what it hears.

Put two antennas on each door, one facing in and one facing the truck. Whichever saw the tag first gives you the direction. Then put a sensor on the door, a beam break, and count only the reads around it. No beam break, no event. A parked pallet never breaks a beam.

Only then does a pile of reads become a sentence. Eight reads and a beam break turn into Pallet 40 left door 2 at 10:42:07. That sentence is the only thing your ERP should ever see.

Drive the forklift yourself

We built the dock above as a simulator. Pick where the forklift goes, switch the rules on one at a time and watch what each antenna hears and what the system makes of it. It uses the same link budget as the range calculator and Wake the tag.

What the model assumes

The dock is invented. Two doors 6 m apart, a staging lane 8.5 m back, a forklift at 1.5 m/s, antennas 1.5 m above the tag. The antenna pattern is a textbook parabola with a 70° beam, capped at 20 dB front-to-back. The panel penalty is 20 dB each way, which is a design target, not a datasheet figure for any product. No reflections.

The tag is an NXP UCODE 9, which wakes at about -24 dBm. The reader is an Impinj E710 in dense-readers mode, which hears -88 dBm at the chip. Those are datasheet figures. A finished reader with cables and a filter will do a little worse.

If your dock behaves differently from this one, you’re probably right and the model is wrong. Walk it with a handheld before you trust either.

If you’re signing the PO, ask the integrator how the system decides which door and which direction. Don’t ask how far the reader reads.

Next step

Tell us what you are trying to trace.

Describe the flow: what arrives, what happens to it and what leaves. We will tell you what it takes to capture it.